New York bank making mostly SBA Express loans and lines: $32K median since FY2020, 8.75% median rate (last 12 months), collateral required. Best for small NY businesses.
What the financing costs, normalized so lenders can be compared.
How and how fast you pay it back, and how flexible it is.
Who qualifies and what you have to put on the line.
How fast you get funded and how the lender treats you.
Who actually stands behind the lender: legal entity, registration, and how long the business and its website have existed. Checked against public registries.
Best for: New York businesses that want a small SBA Express loan or line of credit; its median SBA loan in the last 12 months was $65,500.
Not for: Businesses outside New York (373 of 375 SBA loans since FY2020 went to New York firms) or anyone who needs money within days.
Lender List verdict: Five Star Bank approved 30 SBA 7(a) loans worth $7.0 million in the 12 months to June 2026 at an 8.75% median starting rate, mostly SBA Express. A sound local option for small loans and lines, but it publishes almost no SBA terms.
Updated 2026-11-14 by the Lender List editorial team.
| Five Star Bank | |
|---|---|
| Lender type | FDIC-insured bank (cert 659); SBA Express and PLP lender; Active |
| Founded / HQ / Parent | 1881 / Warsaw, NY / Financial Institutions, Inc. |
| Products | SBA 7(a) and SBA Express loans and lines |
| Amounts | SBA data shows loans from $1,000 to $3,000,000; median $32,000 since FY2020, $65,500 last 12 months |
| Cost | 8.75% median starting rate (last 12 months) |
| Funding speed | Not published; SBA loans typically take several weeks or longer |
Five Star Bank is a Warsaw, NY community bank founded in 1881 (FDIC lists Rochester as its main-office city), with 48 offices and about $6.3 billion in assets at June 30, 2026. Owned by Financial Institutions, Inc., it is not the unrelated Five Star Bank in Rancho Cordova, California.
Five Star Bank makes SBA 7(a) loans mostly through SBA Express (358 of 375 approvals since FY2020), with 17 under the Preferred Lenders Program. Its site gives no SBA terms, so figures below are SBA data.
Five Star Bank's 30 SBA 7(a) loans in the 12 months to June 2026 carried an 8.75% median starting rate (7.50% to 9.50%), about Prime plus 1.25 to 2 points as Prime fell from 7.50% to 6.75%. 16 of 30 were variable. Add the SBA guaranty fee: 2% of the guaranteed share up to $150,000, 3% on $150,001 to $700,000.
Worked example: a $350,000, 10-year standard 7(a) loan at 8.75% costs $4,386.44 a month ($176,372.35 total interest). The $7,875 guaranty fee lifts the APR to about 9.28%. At the SBA's 11.5% cap for this size (Prime 7.00% plus 4.5%), it is $4,920.84. Its typical $65,500 loan at 8.75% over 10 years runs $820.89 a month.
Five Star Bank publishes no credit-score, revenue or time-in-business minimum for its SBA loans.
| Requirement | Five Star Bank minimum |
|---|---|
| Credit score | Lender does not publish |
| Equity injection | 10%+ for startups and changes of ownership (SBA rule) |
| Collateral | All 375 SBA loans since FY2020 collateralized (SBA data) |
| Guarantee | Personal guarantee from 20%+ owners |
Compare SBA Express loans, New York peer TD Bank or national Newtek.
Is Five Star Bank a Good Bank? Mostly yes. Five Star Bank dates to 1881, is FDIC-insured and has no charge-offs on 375 SBA loans since FY2020. BBB rates it A+ (not accredited, 34 complaints in 3 years); Trustpilot has 0 reviews. It agreed to a $29.5 million auto-repossession class settlement in 2025; no current FDIC, CFPB or NY DFS enforcement order found.
Where Is Five Star Bank Headquartered? In Warsaw, New York. Five Star Bank and its parent, Financial Institutions, Inc., give Warsaw as headquarters, while FDIC records list Rochester as the main-office city. The bank had 48 offices and about $6.3 billion in assets at June 30, 2026.
How Long Does Five Star Bank Take to Close an SBA Loan? Five Star Bank does not publish a closing time. Most of its SBA loans use SBA Express, the SBA's streamlined 7(a) program, yet SBA loans typically take several weeks or longer. Appraisals and real estate collateral add time, so apply early.
Does Five Star Bank Lend to Startups? Yes, occasionally. SBA data shows 26 of Five Star Bank's 375 SBA loans since FY2020 went to startups, including 6 of 30 in the 12 months to June 2026. Expect a 10%+ equity injection, collateral and a personal guarantee from 20%+ owners.
Lender List is independent and free to use. We never sell borrower information. See how we make money and our methodology.
Last verified 2026-11-14. Pricing and terms are provider-stated or third-party-reported and vary by offer; confirm with the lender before applying.
Best for: New York businesses that want a small SBA Express loan or line of credit; its median SBA loan in the last 12 months was $65,500.
Not for: Businesses outside New York (373 of 375 SBA loans since FY2020 went to New York firms) or anyone who needs money within days.
Lender List verdict: Five Star Bank approved 30 SBA 7(a) loans worth $7.0 million in the 12 months to June 2026 at an 8.75% median starting rate, mostly SBA Express. A sound local option for small loans and lines, but it publishes almost no SBA terms.
Updated 2026-11-14 by the Lender List editorial team.
| Five Star Bank | |
|---|---|
| Lender type | FDIC-insured bank (cert 659); SBA Express and PLP lender; Active |
| Founded / HQ / Parent | 1881 / Warsaw, NY / Financial Institutions, Inc. |
| Products | SBA 7(a) and SBA Express loans and lines |
| Amounts | SBA data shows loans from $1,000 to $3,000,000; median $32,000 since FY2020, $65,500 last 12 months |
| Cost | 8.75% median starting rate (last 12 months) |
| Funding speed | Not published; SBA loans typically take several weeks or longer |
Five Star Bank is a Warsaw, NY community bank founded in 1881 (FDIC lists Rochester as its main-office city), with 48 offices and about $6.3 billion in assets at June 30, 2026. Owned by Financial Institutions, Inc., it is not the unrelated Five Star Bank in Rancho Cordova, California.
Five Star Bank makes SBA 7(a) loans mostly through SBA Express (358 of 375 approvals since FY2020), with 17 under the Preferred Lenders Program. Its site gives no SBA terms, so figures below are SBA data.
Five Star Bank's 30 SBA 7(a) loans in the 12 months to June 2026 carried an 8.75% median starting rate (7.50% to 9.50%), about Prime plus 1.25 to 2 points as Prime fell from 7.50% to 6.75%. 16 of 30 were variable. Add the SBA guaranty fee: 2% of the guaranteed share up to $150,000, 3% on $150,001 to $700,000.
Worked example: a $350,000, 10-year standard 7(a) loan at 8.75% costs $4,386.44 a month ($176,372.35 total interest). The $7,875 guaranty fee lifts the APR to about 9.28%. At the SBA's 11.5% cap for this size (Prime 7.00% plus 4.5%), it is $4,920.84. Its typical $65,500 loan at 8.75% over 10 years runs $820.89 a month.
Five Star Bank publishes no credit-score, revenue or time-in-business minimum for its SBA loans.
| Requirement | Five Star Bank minimum |
|---|---|
| Credit score | Lender does not publish |
| Equity injection | 10%+ for startups and changes of ownership (SBA rule) |
| Collateral | All 375 SBA loans since FY2020 collateralized (SBA data) |
| Guarantee | Personal guarantee from 20%+ owners |
Compare SBA Express loans, New York peer TD Bank or national Newtek.
Is Five Star Bank a Good Bank? Mostly yes. Five Star Bank dates to 1881, is FDIC-insured and has no charge-offs on 375 SBA loans since FY2020. BBB rates it A+ (not accredited, 34 complaints in 3 years); Trustpilot has 0 reviews. It agreed to a $29.5 million auto-repossession class settlement in 2025; no current FDIC, CFPB or NY DFS enforcement order found.
Where Is Five Star Bank Headquartered? In Warsaw, New York. Five Star Bank and its parent, Financial Institutions, Inc., give Warsaw as headquarters, while FDIC records list Rochester as the main-office city. The bank had 48 offices and about $6.3 billion in assets at June 30, 2026.
How Long Does Five Star Bank Take to Close an SBA Loan? Five Star Bank does not publish a closing time. Most of its SBA loans use SBA Express, the SBA's streamlined 7(a) program, yet SBA loans typically take several weeks or longer. Appraisals and real estate collateral add time, so apply early.
Does Five Star Bank Lend to Startups? Yes, occasionally. SBA data shows 26 of Five Star Bank's 375 SBA loans since FY2020 went to startups, including 6 of 30 in the 12 months to June 2026. Expect a 10%+ equity injection, collateral and a personal guarantee from 20%+ owners.
Lender List is independent and free to use. We never sell borrower information. See how we make money and our methodology.
Last verified 2026-11-14. Pricing and terms are provider-stated or third-party-reported and vary by offer; confirm with the lender before applying.
Saratoga Springs, NY private credit advisory arranging $50K–$20M working capital: lines of credit, term loans, ABL, equi...
SBA Preferred Lender bank: SBA 7(a) up to $5M plus SBA 504, 8.0% median fixed rate (last 12 months), collateral required...
SBA Preferred Lender in ME and NH: SBA 7(a) and Express up to $1.75M, 7.75% median rate (last 12 months), collateral req...
Louisville SBA Preferred Lender: 7(a) and 504 loans up to $5M, Express to $500K, 7.75% median starting rate, startups OK...
SBA Preferred Lender bank: SBA 7(a) up to $5M plus SBA 504, 9.25% median rate (last 12 months), mostly variable, 10%+ do...
SBA Preferred Lender for MN, WI and ND owners: 7(a), 504, Express and CAPLine to $5M, median 9.25% variable, ~10-yr term...